New on the blog: what languages people speak on Revospring, and when the world logs on. Read the post →
Outside of your informative posts about how harmful Stella Maris and Supervillain are, there’s barely any criticism about the 2 stories which makes me wonder if the general fandom is reading different versions of the stories that doesn’t support colonisation. Supervillain only gets praised for how Tetora monologues about his insecurities while the most people talk about Stella Maris is the Chiakana shipbait.
Unfortunately, the fandom has always generally preferred to focus on emotionally satisfying character moments over the political themes underlying the narrative of Ensemble Stars. When the politics do get acknowledged, there's also always a crowd of people looking to fold those politics into their emotional satisfaction or broader enjoyment of a fictional story that is often, by its very nature, voyeuristic. In the case of stories like Supervillain and Stella Maris, this amounts to treating them as morally complex and mature, all while the way they depict conflict and the conclusions at which they arrive are ultimately anti-activism, pro-imperialism, and frankly anti-Ryukyuan. Simultaneously, Indigenous or Indigenous-coded suffering becomes a catalyst for the growth of the Japanese characters without actually giving Indigenous characters agency in their own story. I find the Okinawa Arc especially creepy because it mirrors the way Okinawan resistance gets talked about in the real world. The story depicts it as unusually violent, manipulated by more powerful figures, contrary to the greater good, and an obstacle for the protagonists. In Stella Maris in particular, we see Hoshijima is told to bear and adapt to a burden from the mainland that is framed as necessary growth. Hoshijima has to accept Project-ATLANTIS for its own material security and economic development. This draws a parallel to the way the burden of military bases are placed on Okinawa and defended as necessary, practical, and tied to its security, development, and economy. In the past year, I've had the opportunity to talk to some RYUSEITAI fans who shared their discomfort with the Okinawa Arc. I hope more people are willing to come forward and talk about it openly, because it really is a disturbing series of stories.
Revospring uses Markdown for formatting
*italic text* for italic text
**bold text** for bold text
[link](https://example.com) for link